Why are Bison using road corridors in the first place?
What is the extent of the problem?
Who is responsible for managing the highways and the wildlife that are on the highways?
Factors Involved In Wood Bison Collisions
Traffic Factors Wildlife Factors Seasonal and Diurnal Factors
What can highway managers do to reduce collisions with Wood Bison?
Wood Bison Vehicle Collisions in Northwestern Canada
Northwest Territories Yukon Territory Alberta British Columbia
Northwest Territories
Yukon Territory
Alberta
British Columbia
Back to top
One consequence of the reintroduction of Wood Bison to the Canadian northwestern boreal forest is that several reintroduced herds have suffered significant mortality caused by vehicle collisions.
In March 1996, less than one year after reintroduction, the Etthithun Lake herd suffered 20% mortality, when 3 out of 15 animals were killed by collisions with vehicles.
In the Nordquist Herd, vehicle collisions are the primary cause of Wood Bison mortality.
Highway 3, the Yellowknife Highway, is the only road to Yellowknife, and it runs right through the middle of the core range for the Mackenzie Herd. In 2007, 30 Wood Bison were killed by vehicle collisions.
Bison can be encountered on the following roads in northwestern Canada:
One of the difficulties in reducing wildlife vehicle collisions is that different agencies are responsible for the components of the issue, and they often have conflicting mandates.
Jurisdiction
Wildlife
Highways
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Department of Transportation
Department of Environment
Department of Highways and Public Works
Ministry of Sustainable Resource Development
Ministry of Transportation
Ministry of Environment
Public Works and Government Services Canada
Traffic volume
Traffic speed
Factors that influence Wood Bison behaviour and movement near roads are extremely important in understanding why bison vehicle collisions occur.
Wood Bison density
Wood Bison herd on the highway
Photo courtesy of John Nishi
Wood Bison behaviour
Alaska Highway
Photo courtesy of Colin Leake
Predator prey relationships – herd animals need good sightlines to avoid predators and highways and wide rights of way provide this. Wood Bison become conditioned to the wide open highway environment
Fight or flight response - Wood Bison have adapted to avoid predators that approach low to the ground and from the rear or side. They have few adaptations or hereditary experience to deal with a "predator" that approaches at an extremely fast, constant speed from one direction. Their fight or flight "zones" - the areas within which they are comfortable or agitated, become unpredictable
Social hierarchy - In herd animals, age, gender, and dominance rank provide strong motivations for behavioural responses to stimuli
Herd vs individuals - the individual animal may react differently if it is alone or within its herd group. Fight/flight zones and social distance (the area within which other bison are tolerated), may vary if the animal is alone or within a herd
Relationships Among Personal, Social and Flight Distances for Bison
Adapted from Fowler, 1995
The diagram below, from the work of Dr. T. Grandin, Colorado State University, uses an example of a cow being approached by a handler to illustrate the complex nature of the animal's reaction to stimuli. Wood Bison reaction to approaching predators or vehicles may involve some of the same factors.
Flight Zone and Point of Balance for Cattle
http://www.grandin.com/behaviour/principles/flight.zone.html
This diagram illustrates the general flight zone of an animal.
Seasonal Patterns
Information available on the highest risk times of day and highest risk months for Wood Bison collisions comes from two sources, the Northwest Territories,
The Northwest Territories seasonal and diurnal data is shown in greater detail below, but in summary, for NWT highways, the highest risk months are August to November, and generally, the highest risk times of day are at night, sunset and sunrise.
ICBC data indicated that for the BC portion of the Alaska Highway, the highest numbers of collisions occur in January and November, and the peak frequency of collisions occurs between 12:00 - 2:00 am and 4:00 - 6:00 pm. However, this is based on only a small sample size of 17 collisions between 1996 and 2005, and the actual number of collisions is likely much higher.
Recent seasonal and diurnal studies in northern BC on collision data involving moose, deer, elk and bear, indicate that high risk months and high risk times of day can vary significantly by geographic location. More detailed site specific research for each Wood Bison herd, similar to NWT analyses shown below, needs to be carried out. Diurnal Patterns
Low and changing light levels at dawn, dusk, and during the night increase the risk of Wood Bison collisions for a number of reasons:
Poster Used Along the Alaska Highway to Emphasize
the Difficulty of Seeing Wood Bison at Night
Poster courtesy of Public Works and Government Services Canada and the Wildlife Collision Prevention Program
There are a variety of mitigative techniques that can be employed to reduce the risk of encountering wildlife on the road. Go to the What Can Highway Managers Do? page for a general discussion of wildlife collision mitigation. This section will discuss mitigative options that are Wood Bison specific. Vegetation Management and Habitat Alteration Away from the Highway
or Right of Way
Lure Wood Bison away from the roadside area by:
Vegetation Management/Habitat Alteration in the Right of Way
Implement vegetation management practices to make forage in the roadside area unappealing by:
Unmowed strip adjacent to the
treeline on BC portion of the
June 2008
Photos courtesy of Colin Leake
Exclusion Fencing
Due to the large size of Wood Bison and the extent of their range, wildlife fencing is not an option. Several Wood Bison herds have escaped from strongly built paddocks which were intended to contain them for several years. Bison Warning Signs
The effectiveness of wildlife warning signs is difficult to assess. Studies suggest that wildlife warning signage does not reduce wildlife collision rates. However, jurisdictions do have a responsibility to notify drivers of hazards that they might encounter while driving. Drivers need to know that wildlife warning sign locations are in areas of high wildlife usage and not randomly scattered across the landscape.
In order to make signs as effective as possible the following should be considered:
One consequence of non traditional signage is that unusual signs attract thieves - build extra into your budget or produce souvenir size signs for sale.
Examples of bison warning signs are shown on the Wood Bison Resources page.
Highway and right of way maintenance in the winter
Harassment/Hazing
Wildlife Transfers/Relocations/Culls/Hunting
Enforced Speed Reduction This would be effective, especially during the night hours, but little or no public support exists. For any mitigation that is implemented, managers should:
Watch for the Signs
What do those signs really mean? A Wildlife Warning Sign warns of a hazard ahead, and advises drivers to be cautious. The sign does not require drivers to slow down to a particular speed, unless there is an adjacent speed limit sign posted as well. Wildlife warning signs are placed in areas of frequent wildlife use or high collision risk locations. Drivers must obey wildlife warning signs and any associated speed changes. Drivers must not disregard the signs even if they have been seen many times before. Driver complacency is dangerous.
What do those signs really mean?
A Wildlife Warning Sign warns of a hazard ahead, and advises drivers to be cautious. The sign does not require drivers to slow down to a particular speed, unless there is an adjacent speed limit sign posted as well.
Wildlife warning signs are placed in areas of frequent wildlife use or high collision risk locations.
Drivers must obey wildlife warning signs and any associated speed changes. Drivers must not disregard the signs even if they have been seen many times before. Driver complacency is dangerous.
Reduce Speed
Speed is one of the most common factors in vehicle collisions. Speed:
Reduces the drivers ability to steer away from objects in the roadway Causes drivers to overdrive their headlights at night Extends the distance required to stop Increases the force of impact, in the event of a collision With good road conditions, drivers tend to increase their speed. Some studies suggest that wildlife vehicle collisions occur more than expected on clear nights, on dry road conditions and on long straight stretches. Drivers may tend to be more cautious on curves or in poor weather By maintaining the posted speed, drivers can compensate for increased risk.
With good road conditions, drivers tend to increase their speed. Some studies suggest that wildlife vehicle collisions occur more than expected on clear nights, on dry road conditions and on long straight stretches. Drivers may tend to be more cautious on curves or in poor weather
By maintaining the posted speed, drivers can compensate for increased risk.
Poster Used Along the Alaska Highway to Emphasize Speed Danger
Poster courtesy of the Wildlife Collision Prevention Program and Public Works and Government Services Canada
Think "What If...?"
Mental preparation is a useful tool. Think about and predict what you might do if an animal suddenly appeared in front of you or ran towards your vehicle. It is better to think about and learn how to avoid an encounter with wildlife, than have to react to a dangerous situation when you are unprepared.
Drive Defensively
Drivers and passengers should actively watch for: Wildlife - on the road, in the ditch, on the shoulder, and in the right of way Movement on or alongside the road Flickering head lights of oncoming cars or tail lights of the vehicles in front of you - which may be an animal crossing the road Roadside reflectors that disappear/reappear, which might indicate an animal crossing in front of them Watch out between dusk and dawn. Light levels are low, and animals are active. Wood Bison collisions often occur at dusk, pre-dawn and during the night. Be prepared.
Use Your Vehicle
Maintain your vehicle - Keep head lights, signal lights, and tail lights clean and in good working order. Clean your windshield, inside and out, once a week, or more if someone smokes, and check and repair windshield wiper blades. Keep head lights properly aligned to avoid blinding other drivers and optimize road coverage. Wear your seatbelt at all times. Honk your horn or flash your lights to scare animals off the road. In a 3 lane situation, when it is safe to do so, and when it is not impeding other traffic, drive in the middle lane to provide more distance from the ditch. Use high beams when it is safe to do so, and scan the road ahead with quick glances. At night, use the high beams of the vehicle in front of you to extend your effective sight distance.
Investigate an "Electronic Stability Control" system for your vehicle
Electronic Stability Control ("ESC") helps you maintain control of your vehicle in emergency avoidance manoeuvres such as swerving around wildlife. ESC detects and corrects loss of vehicle control. If you skid, ESC works together with your antilock braking system and automatically applies braking to the correct wheel to help you regain control. ESC reacts instantly, often correcting your direction before you know you are skidding.
Click here for more information on ESC.
Slow Down - collision avoidance and driver response time are improved at slower speeds Anticipate unpredictable behaviour from all wildlife Determine what the animal is doing and where it is going Wood Bison are herd animals. Where there is one animal, there is almost always more.
More detailed information on animal behaviour is found on The Wildlife Factor page. Please have a look there.
The information below was presented at the Bison and Roads Committee meeting in December 2006, at Fort Nelson, BC, by John Nishi, Northwest Territories, Department of Environment and Natural Resources, with additional information provided by Nic Larter, Dehcho Regional Biologist, Department of Environment & Natural Resources, Ft. Simpson, Northwest Territories.
Other sources of information were:
Herd
Population
(estimated)
Comments
Mackenzie
2000
(2000 count)
Hwy 3, Yellowknife Hwy, right in the middle of the home range
Collisions commonly occur between Mackenzie River Crossing and Yellowknife
Approx 84% of NWT Wood Bison vehicle collisions involve this herd
Largest herd in Canada
Nahanni
400
(2004 count)
Highway 7, Liard Hwy
Approx 15% of NWT Wood Bison collisions involve this herd (12 mortalities 2000-2005)
Slave River Lowlands
500
Diseased herd
Highway 5, Fort Smith Hwy
Approx 1% of NWT Wood Bison collisions involve this herd
The Northwest Territories are concerned with encroachment and infection from the diseased Wood Bison National Park population into the NWT herds and with maintaining the disease free status of the Alberta Hay-Zama herd.
The Northwest Territories has conducted considerable analysis of Wood Bison vehicle collisions occurring in their jurisdiction.
Wood Bison Mortalities Caused by Vehicle Collisions 1989-2006, NWT
Out of 123 Wood Bison vehicle collisions from 1989 to 2006:
Distribution of Wood Bison Collisions along Highway 3, NWT
Early collisions on Highway 3 were to the south, then extended north as herd increased in number and distribution
Number of Wood Bison Killed Per Collision, NWT
Seasonal / Diurnal Patterns of Wood Bison Collisions, NWT
Sex and Age of Wood Bison Killed in Vehicle Collisions, NWT
Sex/Age of Bison hit is poorly reported, but adult females
seem to be highest frequency.
Nahanni Herd Specifics
Action Items Needed in NWT
Collision Mitigation Efforts in NWT
What has actually been implemented in NWT…
The information below was presented at the Bison and Roads Committee meeting in December 2006, at Fort Nelson, BC, by Tom Jung, Senior Biologist, Philip Merchant, and Todd Powell, Yukon Territory, Department of Environment.
Aishihik Herd
Yukon Management Plan (1998-2003)
Collision Mitigation Efforts in the Yukon
Tried and found unsuccessful.....
Other Mitigation Options
The Yukon Territory is very concerned with BC Nordquist Herd as it impacts a critical highway that is used and relied on year round.
The information below was presented at the Bison and Roads Committee meeting in December 2006, at Fort Nelson, BC, by Dave Moyles, Area Wildlife Biologist and Jacki Gerwing, Fish & Wildlife Officer, Alberta Ministry of Sustainable Resource Development.
Hay-Zama Herd
Since Sept 2006
This Wood Bison vehicle collision took place on he Zama Road in Alberta in October 2007.
5 Wood Bison from the Hay-Zama herd were killed.
2 vehicles were involved; 1 vehicle was write-off.
The two drivers were unhurt.
It was early morning, dark, and foggy. The gravel road was slick and had no snow cover to highlight the bison.
Photos courtesy of Kyland Pennoyer, Fish and Wildlife Officer, Alberta Ministry of Sustainable Development
Mitigation Efforts
The information below was presented at the Bison and Roads Committee meeting in December 2006, at Fort Nelson, BC, by Mike Rowe, Biologist and Dean Maclean, Senior Park Ranger, British Columbia Ministry of Environment, with input from Colin Leake, Public Works and Government Services Canada, and Roy Rea, University of Northern British Columbia.
Nordquist herd on the Alaska Highway
January 2007
Photos courtesy of Conrad Thiessen
Pink Mountain Herd (Plains Bison)
Did you learn something new? Do you have a wildlife-vehicle accident story to share? Is this type of public education and awareness necessary?
Copyright © 2004 - 2010, Wildlife Collision Prevention Program. All Rights Reserved. Powered by SiteCMTM— web content management made easy by ideaLEVER Solutions.